Meta-Analysis of Psychosocial Interventions for Caregivers of People with Dementia
Henry Brodaty MD, FRANZCP, FRACP
School of Psychiatry, University of New South Wales, Sydney, Australia; and
Academic Department for Old Age Psychiatry, Prince of Wales Hospital, Randwick, New South Wales, Australia
Search for more papers by this authorAlisa Green B. Sc (Psychol). Hons
Academic Department for Old Age Psychiatry, Prince of Wales Hospital, Randwick, New South Wales, Australia
Search for more papers by this authorAnnette Koschera PhD
Academic Department for Old Age Psychiatry, Prince of Wales Hospital, Randwick, New South Wales, Australia
Search for more papers by this authorHenry Brodaty MD, FRANZCP, FRACP
School of Psychiatry, University of New South Wales, Sydney, Australia; and
Academic Department for Old Age Psychiatry, Prince of Wales Hospital, Randwick, New South Wales, Australia
Search for more papers by this authorAlisa Green B. Sc (Psychol). Hons
Academic Department for Old Age Psychiatry, Prince of Wales Hospital, Randwick, New South Wales, Australia
Search for more papers by this authorAnnette Koschera PhD
Academic Department for Old Age Psychiatry, Prince of Wales Hospital, Randwick, New South Wales, Australia
Search for more papers by this authorAbstract
OBJECTIVES: To review published reports of interventions for caregivers (CGs) of persons with dementia, excluding respite care, and provide recommendations to clinicians.
DESIGN: Meta-analytical review. Electronic databases and key articles were searched for controlled trials, preferably randomized, published in English from 1985 to 2001 inclusive. Thirty studies were located and scored according to set criteria, and the interventions' research quality and clinical significance were judged.
SETTING: Home or noninstitutional environment.
PARTICIPANTS: Informal CGs—persons providing unpaid care at home or in a noninstitutional setting.
MEASUREMENTS: The primary measures were psychological morbidity and burden. Other varied outcome measures such as CG coping skills and social support were combined with measures of psychological distress and burden to form a main outcome measure.
RESULTS: The quality of research increased over the 17 years. Results from 30 studies (34 interventions) indicated, at most-current follow-up, significant benefits in caregiver psychological distress (random effect size (ES) = 0.31; 95% confidence interval (CI) = 0.13–0.50), caregiver knowledge (ES = 0.51; CI = 0.05–0.98), any main caregiver outcome measure (ES = 0.32; CI = 0.15–0.48), and patient mood (ES = 0.68; CI = 0.30–1.06), but not caregiver burden (ES = 0.09; CI = −0.09–0.26). There was considerable variability in outcome, partly because of differences in methodology and intervention technique. Elements of successful interventions could be identified. Success was more likely if, in addition to CGs, patients were involved. Four of seven studies indicated delayed nursing home admission.
CONCLUSION: Some CG interventions can reduce CG psychological morbidity and help people with dementia stay at home longer. Programs that involve the patients and their families and are more intensive and modified to CGs' needs may be more successful. Future research should try to improve clinicians' abilities to prescribe interventions.
REFERENCES
- 1 Max W, Webber PA, Fox PJ. Alzheimer's disease. The unpaid burden of caring. J Aging Health 1995; 7: 179–199.
- 2 Brodaty H, Green A. Family caregivers for people with dementia. In: J O'Brien, D Ames, A Burns, eds. Dementia, 2nd Ed. London: Arnold, 2000, pp. 193–205.
- 3 Baumgarten M, Battista RN, Infante-Rivard C et al. The psychological and physical health of family members caring for an elderly person with dementia. J Clin Epidemiol 1992; 45: 61–70.
- 4 Rosenthal CJ, Sulman J, Marshall VW. Depressive symptoms in family caregivers of long-stay patients. Gerontologist 1993; 33: 249–257.
- 5 Schulz R, Vistainer P, Williamson GM. Psychiatric and physical morbidity effects of caregiving. J Gerontol 1990; 45: P181–P191.
- 6 Brodaty H, Hadzi-Pavlovic D. Psychosocial effects on carers of living with persons with dementia. Aust N Z J Psychiatry 1990; 24: 351–361.
- 7 Brodaty H, McGilchrist C, Harris L et al. Time until institutionalization and death in patients with dementia: Role of caregiver training and risk factors. Arch Neurol 1993; 50: 643–650.
- 8 Gottlieb BH, Johnson J. Respite programs for caregivers of persons with dementia: A review with practice implications. Aging Ment Health 2000; 4: 119–129.
- 9 Clarke M, Oxman AD, eds. Cochrane Reviewers Handbook 4.1.1 In: The Cochrane Library, Oxford: Update Software. 2000.
- 10 Brennan FP, Moore SM, Smyth KA. The effects of a special computer network on caregivers of persons with Alzheimer's disease. Nurs Res 1995; 44: 166–172.
- 11 Bass DM, McClendon MJ, Flatley Brennan P et al. The buffering effect of a computer support network on caregiver strain. J Aging Health 1998; 10: 20–43.
- 12 Brodaty H, Gresham M. Effect of a training programme to reduce stress in carers of patients with dementia. BMJ 1989; 299: 1375–1379.
- 13
Brodaty H,
Gresham M,
Luscombe G.
The Prince Henry Hospital dementia caregivers training programme.
Int J Geriatr Psychiatry
1997; 12: 183–192.
10.1002/(SICI)1099-1166(199702)12:2<183::AID-GPS584>3.0.CO;2-J CASPubMedWeb of Science®Google Scholar
- 14 Brodaty H, Peters KE. Cost effectiveness of a training program for dementia carers. Int Psychogeriatr 1991; 3: 11–21.
- 15 Brodaty H, Roberts K, Peters K. Quasi-experimental evaluation of an educational model for dementia caregivers. Int J Geriatr Psychiatry 1994; 9: 195–204.
- 16 Chang BL. Cognitive-behavioural intervention for homebound caregivers of persons with dementia. Nurs Res 1999; 48: 173–182.
- 17 Chiverton P, Caine ED. Education to assist spouses in coping with Alzheimer's disease. A controlled trial. J Am Geriatr Soc 1989; 37: 593–598.
- 18
Chu P,
Edwards J,
Levin R et al. The use of clinical case management for early stage Alzheimer's patients and their families.
Am J Alzheimers Dis Other Demen
2000; 15: 284–290.
10.1177/153331750001500506 Google Scholar
- 19 Dröes RM, Breebaart E, Ettema TP et al. Effect of integrated family support versus day care only on behaviour and mood of patients with dementia. Int Psychogeriatr 1999; 12: 99–115.
- 20 Eloniemi-Sulkava U, Sivenius J et al. Support program for demented patients and their carers: The role of dementia family care coordinator is crucial. In: K Iqbal, DF Swaab, B Winblad et al, eds. Alzheimer's Disease and Related Disorders. West Sussex: John Wiley & Sons, 1999, pp. 795–802.
- 21
Gendron C,
Poitras L,
Dastoor DP et al. Cognitive-behavioral group intervention for spousal caregivers. Findings and clinical considerations.
Clin Gerontol
1996; 17: 3–19.
10.1300/J018v17n01_02 Google Scholar
- 22 Hébert R, Leclerc G, Bravo G et al. Efficacy of a support programme for caregivers of demented patients in the community: A randomized controlled trial. Arch Gerontol Geriatr 1994; 18: 1–14.
- 23 Hébert R, Girouard D, Leclerc G et al. The impact of a support programme for care-givers on the institutionalisation of demented patients. Arch Gerontol Geriatr 1995; 20: 129–134.
- 24 Hinchliffe AC, Hyman IL, Blizard B et al. Behavioural complications of dementia—Can they be treated? Int J Geriatr Psychiatry 1995; 10: 839–847.
- 25 Kahan J, Kemp B, Staples FR et al. Decreasing the burden in families caring for a relative with a dementing illness: A controlled study. J Am Geriatr Soc 1985; 33: 664–670.
- 26
LoGiudice D,
Waltrowicz W,
Brown K et al. Do memory clinics improve the quality of life of carers? A randomized pilot trial.
Int J Geriatr Psychiatry
1999; 14: 626–632.
10.1002/(SICI)1099-1166(199908)14:8<626::AID-GPS990>3.0.CO;2-5 CASPubMedWeb of Science®Google Scholar
- 27 Marriott A, Donaldson C, Tarrier N et al. Effectiveness of cognitive-behavioural family intervention in reducing the burden of care in carers of patients with Alzheimer's disease. Br J Psychiatr 2000; 176: 557–562.
- 28 McCallion P, Toseland RW, Freeman K. An evaluation of a family visit education program. J Am Geriatr Soc 1999; 47: 203–214.
- 29 McCurry SM, Logsdon RG, Vitiello M et al. Successful behavioural treatment for reported sleep problems in elderly caregivers of dementia patients: A controlled study. J Gerontol B Psychol Sci Soc Sci 1998; 53B: P122–P129.
- 30 Mittelman MS, Ferris SH, Shulman E et al. A family intervention to delay nursing home placements of patients with Alzheimer's disease. A randomized controlled trial. JAMA 1996; 276: 1725–1731.
- 31 Mittelman MS, Ferris SH, Shulman E et al. A comprehensive support program. Effect on depression in spouse-caregivers of AD patients. Gerontologist 1995; 35: 792–802.
- 32 Mittelman MS, Ferris SH, Steinberg G et al. An intervention that delays institutionalisation of Alzheimer's disease patients: Treatment of spouse-caregivers. Gerontologist 1993; 33: 730–740.
- 33 Mohide EA, Pringle DM, Streiner DL et al. A randomized trial of family caregiver support in the home management of dementia. J Am Geriatr Soc 1990; 38: 446–454.
- 34 Drummond M, Mohide EA, Tew M et al. Economic evaluation of a support programme for caregivers of demented elderly. Int J Technol Assess Health Care 1991; 7: 209–219.
- 35 Moniz Cook E, Agar S, Gibson GD et al. A preliminary study of the effects of early intervention with people with dementia and their families in a memory clinic. Aging Ment Health 1998; 2: 199–211.
- 36
Morris RG,
Woods RT,
Davies KS et al. The use of a coping strategy focused support group for carers of dementia sufferers.
Counselling Psychol Q
1992; 5: 337–348.
10.1080/09515079208254479 Google Scholar
- 37 Ostwald SK, Hepburn KW, Caron W et al. Reducing caregiver burden. A randomized psychoeducational intervention for caregivers of persons with dementia. Gerontologist 1999; 39: 299–309.
- 38 Quayhagen MP, Quayhagen M. Differential effects of family-based strategies on Alzheimer's disease. Gerontologist 1989; 29: 150–155.
- 39 Quayhagen MP, Quayhagen M, Corbeil RR et al. Coping with dementia. Evaluation of four nonpharmacologic interventions. Int Psychogeriatr 2000; 12: 249–265.
- 40 Riordan J, Bennett A. An evaluation of an augmented domiciliary service to older people with dementia and their carers. Aging Ment Health 1998; 2: 137–143.
- 41
Ripich DN,
Ziol E,
Lee MM.
Longitudinal effects of communication training on caregivers of persons with Alzheimer's disease.
Clin Gerontologist
1998; 19: 37–53.
10.1300/J018v19n02_04 Google Scholar
- 42 Roberts J, Browne G, Milne C et al. Problem-solving counseling for caregivers of the cognitively impaired: Effective for whom? Nurs Res 1999; 48: 162–172.
- 43 Robinson KM. A social skills training program for adult caregivers. Adv Nurs Sci 1988; 10: 59–72.
- 44 Robinson K, Yates K. Effects of two caregiver-training programs on burden and attitude toward help. Arch Psychiatr Nurs 1994; 8: 312–319.
- 45
Teri L,
Logsdon RG,
Uomoto J et al. Behavioral treatment of depression in dementia patients: A controlled clinical trial.
J Gerontol B Psychol Sci Soc Sci
1997; 52B: P159–P166.
10.1093/geronb/52B.4.P159 Google Scholar
- 46
Zanetti O,
Metitieri T,
Bianchetti A et al. Effectiveness of an educational program for demented person's relatives.
Arch Gerontol Geriatr Suppl
1998; 6: 531–538.
10.1016/S0167-4943(98)80078-2 Google Scholar
- 47 Zarit SH, Anthony CR, Boutselis M. Interventions with care givers of dementia patients: Comparison of two approaches. Psychol Aging 1987; 2: 225–232.
- 48
Normand SL.
Tutorial in biostatistics. Meta-analysis. Formulating, evaluating, combining, and reporting.
Stat Med
1999; 18: 321–359.
10.1002/(SICI)1097-0258(19990215)18:3<321::AID-SIM28>3.0.CO;2-P CASPubMedWeb of Science®Google Scholar
- 49 Engels EA, Schmid CH, Terrin N et al. Heterogeneity and statistical significance in meta-analysis: An empirical study of 125 meta-analyses. Stat Med 2000; 19: 1707–1728.
- 50 Hunter JE, Schmidt FL. Methods of Meta-Analysis. Correcting Error and Bias in Research Findings. London: Sage, 1990.
- 51
Olkin I.
Diagnostic statistical procedures in medical meta-analyses.
Stat Med
1999; 18: 2331–2341.
10.1002/(SICI)1097-0258(19990915/30)18:17/18<2331::AID-SIM259>3.0.CO;2-L CASPubMedWeb of Science®Google Scholar
- 52 Cohen J. Statistical Power Analysis for the Behavioural Sciences. London: Lawrence Erlbaum, 1988.
- 53 Clarke M, Oxman AD, eds. Cochrane Reviewers' Handbook 4.0. Review Manager, Version 4.0. Oxford: The Cochrane Collaboration, 1999.
- 54
Hardy R,
Thompson SG.
Detecting and describing heterogeneity in meta-analysis.
Stat Med
1998; 17: 841–856.
10.1002/(SICI)1097-0258(19980430)17:8<841::AID-SIM781>3.0.CO;2-D CASPubMedWeb of Science®Google Scholar
- 55 Gendron CE, Poitras LR, Engels ML et al. Skills training with supporters of the demented. J Am Geriatr Soc 1986; 34: 875–880.
- 56 Sutcliffe C, Larner S. Counselling carers of the elderly at home: A preliminary study. Br J Clin Psychol 1988; 27: 177–178.
- 57 Haley WE, Brown L, Levine EG. Experimental evaluation of the effectiveness of group intervention for dementia caregivers. Gerontologist 1987; 27: 376–382.
- 58 Baldwin BA, Kleeman KM, Stevens GL et al. Family caregiver stress. Clinical assessment and management. Int Psychogeriatr 1989; 1: 185–194.
- 59 Dellasega C. Coping with care-giving. Stress management for caregivers of the elderly. J Psychosoc Nurs Ment Health Serv 1990; 28: 15–22.
- 60 Goodman CC, Pynoos J. A model telephone information and support program for caregivers of Alzheimer's patients. Gerontologist 1990; 30: 399–404.
- 61 Seltzer MM, Litchfield LC, Kapust LR et al. Professional and family collaboration in case management: A hospital-based replication of a community-based study. Soc Work Health Care 1992; 17: 1–22.
- 62 Weinberger M, Gold DT, Divine GW et al. Social service interventions for caregivers of patients with dementia: Impact on health care utilization and expenditures. J Am Geriatr Soc 1993; 41: 153–156.
- 63 Farran CJ, Keane-Hagarty E. Multi-modal intervention strategies for caregivers of persons with dementia. In: E Light, ed. Stress Effects on Family Caregivers of Alzheimer's Patient's: Research and Interventions. New York: Springer Publishing, 1994, pp. 242–259.
- 64 Challis D, Von Abendorff R, Brown P et al. Care management and dementia: An evaluation of the Lewisham Intensive Case Management Scheme. In: S Hunter, ed. Dementia: Challenges and New Directions. London: Jessica Kingsley, 1997, pp. 139–164.
- 65 Burgener SC, Bakas T, Murray C et al. Effective caregiving approaches for patients with Alzheimer's disease. Geriatr Nurs 1998; 19: 121–126.
- 66 Buckwalter KC, Gerdner L, Kohout F et al. A nursing intervention to decrease depression in family caregivers of persons with dementia. Arch Psychiatr Nurs 1999; 13: 80–88.
- 67 Corbeil RR, Quayhagen MP, Quayhagen M. Intervention effects of dementia caregiving interaction. A stress-adaptation modeling approach. J Aging Health 1999; 11: 9–95.
- 68 Perkins RE, Poynton CF. Group counselling for relatives of hospitalized presenile dementia patients: A controlled study. Br J Clin Psychol 1990; 29: 287–295.
- 69 Laird NM, Mosteller F. Some statistical methods for combining experimental results. Int J Tech Assess Health Care 1990; 6: 5–30.